Between heavy snow loads, brutal freeze-thaw cycles, wet springs, and humid summers, a roof in the Upper Valley has a tough job. And with so many historic homes in the region, the “right” roof isn’t just about performance. It’s also about what suits the house.
If you’re planning a roof replacement or a new construction project, here’s how the three most common materials compare, and how to decide which one fits your home.
Standing Seam Metal: Built for Snow
Standing seam metal roofing is a top performer in snow-heavy climates, and it’s easy to see why. Its smooth, interlocking panels let snow slide off easily, and it’s highly durable, energy-efficient, and virtually maintenance-free.
Why homeowners choose it:
- Sheds snow effortlessly
- Long-lasting and low maintenance
- Works on both modern and traditional homes
Things to consider:
- Installation demands precision, including proper allowances for thermal expansion
- Sliding snow can be a factor above walkways, doors, and driveways, so placement matters
Slate: The Heirloom Roof
Slate is a premium material known for its stunning natural look and incredible lifespan. It’s a natural fit for the region’s older homes, and All Starr Roofing specializes in slate restoration for the Upper Valley’s 200-year-old houses. With routine maintenance, a slate roof can last for many years, and All Starr backs slate installations with a 20-year warranty.
Why homeowners choose it:
- Timeless, classic character
- Exceptional longevity
- Adds long-term value to a home
Things to consider:
- Slate is heavy, so the roof framing has to be able to carry the load, and reinforcement may be needed
- It’s a premium investment up front
Architectural Asphalt Shingles: The Versatile Workhorse
Asphalt shingles are a cost-effective, versatile option available in a wide range of colors and styles, some designed to mimic slate or wood shakes. They offer excellent value and reliable performance, which is why they’re so popular. We offer a 25-year warranty on shingles, and we use products from trusted brands like CertainTeed, Pinnacle, and Owens Corning.
Why homeowners choose it:
- Strong value for the price
- Huge variety of colors and styles
- Straightforward installation and repair
Things to consider:
- Typically not as long-lived as slate or metal
- Regular upkeep helps them last, which is where roof care comes in
What About Flat or Low-Slope Sections?
Not every roof is steeply pitched. For additions, porches, or modern designs with low-slope areas, rubber (EPDM) roofing is a common choice because it offers excellent waterproofing and UV resistance. We include a 30-year warranty on all EPDM installations.
How to Choose: Five Questions to Ask
- How old is your home, and what’s its style? Historic homes often look best with slate, metal, or cedar shake.
- Can your roof structure support the material? Slate especially may require reinforcement, and our roof re-decking and framing service can address underlying structural needs.
- How much snow does your property get? Metal’s snow-shedding is a major advantage in heavy-snow areas.
- What’s your budget, short term and long term? Consider lifespan and maintenance, not just the upfront price.
- Are you replacing the roof or layering over it? Ask about re-roofing services to see whether a re-roof is an option for your situation.
Don’t Forget the Extras
The roof surface is only part of the system. Skylights, chimneys, and gutters all affect how well your roof performs. If you’re planning a new roof, it’s a good time to look at windows and skylights, chimney repair, and gutters and downspouts at the same time, so everything is done once and done right.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which roofing material is best for heavy snow? Standing seam metal is a top performer in snow-heavy climates because it sheds snow easily and is highly durable.
Can slate roofs be repaired, or do they always need replacing? Slate can often be restored. We specialize in slate restoration for the region’s older homes and also handle full slate roof replacements.
What warranties do you offer? We offer a 25-year warranty on shingles, a 20-year warranty on slate roofing installations, and a 30-year warranty on EPDM installations.
Do you work on both residential and commercial roofs? Yes. We provide residential and commercial roofing throughout Vermont and New Hampshire.
Do you provide free estimates? Yes. Estimates are free, and we can usually get them done the same day you call.
Which towns do you serve? We serve the Upper Valley, including Hanover, Lebanon, Norwich, Quechee, West Lebanon, and Woodstock.
